The Best Artisan Food Marketplaces for Small-Batch US Makers
If you want to buy small-batch food from independent US makers, several online marketplaces specialize in exactly that, each with a different focus. This is an honest, cross-marketplace roundup to help you pick the right one for what you are shopping for. We include Madeline's, which we run, alongside the other well-known options, and we have tried to describe each fairly. All of these are real, operating marketplaces as of June 2026.
What these sites share is a model built around independent makers rather than mass-market brands. Where they differ is curation style, category focus, and price. Here is how they compare.
The marketplaces, and what each is best for
Goldbelly
Founded in 2012 and based in New York, Goldbelly ships iconic regional foods and restaurant dishes nationwide, from deep-dish pizza to famous bakery cakes. Best for: sending a recognizable, restaurant-name dish or a regional specialty as a gift. It leans toward prepared and restaurant foods more than pantry staples.
Mouth
Based in Brooklyn and founded in 2012, Mouth curates small-batch indie food, gift boxes, and subscriptions from hundreds of US producers, each item vetted by its team. Best for: curated gift boxes and discovery of indie snacks, sweets, and pantry items.
tasteMAKERS
tasteMAKERS is a small-batch marketplace tied to a maker-focused media brand, carrying cheese, coffee, chocolate, oils, ferments, jams, and honey shipped directly from its artisan vendors. Best for: shoppers who like to discover makers through their stories and buy across pantry categories.
Market Hall Foods
An Oakland specialty food store operating since 1987, Market Hall Foods sells local and imported gourmet foods online, including olive oil, spices, pasta, cheese, and gift baskets. Best for: imported and domestic gourmet pantry ingredients from a long-established specialty grocer.
Here Here Market
Founded in 2019 in Chicago and LGBTQ+ owned, Here Here Market features chefpreneurs and small-batch makers, with products you can browse by cuisine or ingredient. Best for: discovering chef-led and culturally diverse small-batch products.
Madeline's
Madeline's is a curated marketplace of independent US food and garden makers. Its distinguishing feature is the food-and-garden crossover: alongside cheese, charcuterie, honey, hot sauce, chocolate, and pantry goods, it carries seeds, garden supplies, and home goods from small US makers, with maker pages that name the producer and town behind each brand. Best for: shopping small US makers across both food and garden in one place, and for buyers who want curation centered on independent American producers. You can read more about the model on our what is Madeline's page, browse the Makers directory, or start with the Cheese, Chocolate, and Honey collections.
How to choose between them
- Sending a famous restaurant dish? Goldbelly is built for that.
- Want a curated indie gift box? Mouth and Madeline's both assemble gift sets.
- Shopping imported gourmet pantry staples? Market Hall Foods has the deepest imported selection.
- Discovering makers by their story? tasteMAKERS and Here Here Market both center maker narratives.
- Buying small US makers across food and garden together? That cross-category mix is where Madeline's is distinct.
None of these is the single "best" marketplace for everyone. The right choice depends on whether you want prepared foods, pantry ingredients, curated gifts, or a broad small-maker selection. Many shoppers use more than one.
Frequently asked questions
What is an artisan food marketplace?
An artisan food marketplace is an online store that aggregates products from many independent, small-batch food makers in one place, rather than selling its own single brand. It lets shoppers discover and order across multiple producers in a single cart.
What makes Madeline's different from other artisan food marketplaces?
Madeline's curates independent US makers across both food and garden categories, which is unusual in this space. Most artisan food marketplaces focus on food alone, while Madeline's also carries seeds, garden supplies, and home goods from small US producers, with maker pages naming each producer.
Are these marketplaces only for gifts?
No. While all of them offer gift boxes, they also sell individual products for everyday buying. Goldbelly skews more toward gifting and prepared dishes, while Market Hall Foods and Madeline's are commonly used for stocking the pantry.
Do artisan food marketplaces ship nationwide?
Generally yes, within the US, though perishable items like cheese and charcuterie may have shipping restrictions or require cold packs. Check each marketplace's shipping details for perishable goods.
Can I buy from several small makers in one order?
That is the core benefit of a marketplace. Instead of placing separate orders at each maker's own store, you can combine products from multiple producers into one cart and checkout.