Tools / Field guides / How to choose olive oil

How to choose olive oil

Buy extra virgin with a harvest date, in dark glass or a tin, in a size you will finish within a few months. Then choose by taste, from mild and buttery to green and peppery.

Coratina Extra Virgin Olive Oil - NEW HARVEST 2025Olive Oil & Vinegar ClubThe Club Bundle

Read the label

Look for Why
Extra virgin The only grade made without refining. It has to pass taste and chemistry tests.
A harvest date Olive oil does not get better with age. The newer, the better.
Dark glass or a tin Light breaks oil down.
Where the olives were grown A named country and region, or a single estate. Bottled in a country is not the same as grown there.
A size you will finish Once opened, it is best within a few months.

Mild to bold

Delicate
Mild, buttery, a little sweetFor baking, fish, eggs and mayonnaise. Arbequina oils often taste this way.
Medium
Fruity and grassy, some biteFor salads, vegetables and dipping bread.
Robust
Green, bitter and pepperyFor steak, beans, hearty soups and finishing. Picual and Coratina oils often taste this way.

The peppery catch at the back of the throat is normal in fresh, robust oil. Bitterness and pepper are part of the flavor, not a flaw.

Olive oil in stockAll best extra virgin olive oils, compared

Extra virgin vs regular olive oil, how to store olive oil and how to choose balsamic vinegar.