Independent shop directory

Cheese shops in New Jersey

10 independent cheese shops in New Jersey, grouped by town, with the street address and website where we have one. Makers use this as a starting list for wholesale. Everyone else uses it to find good food nearby.

Carry Madeline's makers See them on the mapLocal farms in New Jersey

Cape May

  • Seaside Cheese Company
    Cape May, NJ
  • The Cheese Chop
    30 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ

Elizabeth

  • Beecher's Handmade Cheese
    Elizabeth, NJ

Frenchtown

  • Olive with a Twist
    Frenchtown, NJ

Jersey City

Lawrence Township

Maplewood

Montclair

Paterson

  • Abuelito Cheese
    Paterson, NJ

Princeton

  • Olsson's Fine Foods
    53 Palmer Square West, Princeton, NJ
New Jersey by type of shop

Run a shop? Carry Madeline's makers

Madeline's works with more than 200 independent makers: creameries, salumi makers, beekeepers, roasters, jam and hot sauce kitchens. Tell us what your shelves need and we will introduce you to makers who sell wholesale.

Make food? Getting onto these shelves

Start with the shops closest to you, bring samples and a one-page price sheet, and know your wholesale price before you walk in. These help: the wholesale price calculator, how to price food products for wholesale, where to sell artisan food online, and the directory of co-packers, kitchens, packaging suppliers and distributors. Madeline's also sets up wholesale ordering for makers, and lists makers on the marketplace.

Questions

How many cheese shops are in New Jersey?

This directory lists 10 independent cheese shops in New Jersey. National chains are left out.

Where does this list come from?

From OpenStreetMap, the open map that anyone can edit. We keep independent shops and leave out national chains. If a shop is missing or has closed, fix it on OpenStreetMap or send us a note through the form above and we will update it.

I make food. Will these shops buy from me?

Many will. Co-ops, cheese shops and country stores are where most small makers get their first wholesale accounts. Ask for the buyer, bring samples, and have a wholesale price that leaves the shop its margin.

Can I buy from small makers without going to a shop?

Yes. Madeline's is an online farmstand. Makers ship cheese, honey, preserves, coffee and more straight from their own kitchens and farms, one cart and one checkout.

Other states

Shop data © OpenStreetMap contributors, available under the Open Database License. Listings are independent businesses and are not affiliated with Madeline's unless they say so.