Olive Cheddar
Olive Cheddar
Made and shipped by Keystone Cheese
Ships from Bethlehem, PA, shipping from $12.71. Anything else from this maker rides in the same box.
Ships cold. Packed with ice packs in insulated packaging and sent Monday to Wednesday so it never sits over a weekend.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Anything else from Keystone Cheese ships in the same box. See what else they make
Ordering 10 or more, any makers? 10% off in the cart. Build a gift around it 25 or more? Ask for a quote
Olive Cheddar is a creamy white cheddar studded with finely chopped green and black olives, sold in 6 to 10 oz blocks by Keystone Cheese. The briny olives play against the smooth, creamy cheddar. It is an American Cheese Society winner.
At a glance
- Size: 6 to 10 oz blocks
- Base: Creamy white cheddar
- Add-ins: Finely chopped green and black olives
- Accolade: American Cheese Society winner
- Origin: Wisconsin
- Vendor: Keystone Cheese
- Shipping: Perishable; ships Monday through Wednesday, never over the weekend
Best for
- Topping garlic bread
- Serving with wheat crackers
- Party dips and appetizers
- Antipasto-style boards
- A gift for an olive lover
How to use
Melt it over garlic bread, serve it with wheat crackers, or blend it into a dip served with pretzels for a party appetizer. It also adds a briny note to a snack board.
Flavor profile
Smooth, creamy white cheddar with the salty, briny pop of green and black olives.
About Keystone Cheese
Keystone Cheese is a Wisconsin purveyor of farm-fresh and aged cheeses, shipped straight from the creamery to keep flavor and texture at their peak.
Sold by Keystone Cheese, based in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania.
Learn more: What Pairs Well With a Cheese Board?



- Packed and shipped by the maker, never a warehouse
- Mix any makers in one cart, one checkout, no account
- Perishables go out Monday to Wednesday in insulated packaging
More from Keystone Cheese
Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. Ships in the same box as this one, so no extra shipping.
-
Blueberry Infused Cheddar
Regular price From $9.00Sale price From $9.00 Regular price$0.00 -
LaClare Garlic & Herb Goat Cheese
Regular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular price -
LaClare Chipotle Honey Goat Cheese
Regular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular price -
Cranberry Infused Cheddar
Regular price From $9.00Sale price From $9.00 Regular price$0.00
Pairs well with
From other makers on Madeline's. Each maker ships its own box.
-
Mixed Berry Jam
Vendor:Miss Kim'sRegular price $5.99Sale price $5.99 Regular price -
"Precious Cargo" Horseradish Cheddar
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $7.60Sale price $7.60 Regular price -
Dark Honey
Vendor:Hidden Hollow HoneyRegular price From $11.00Sale price From $11.00 Regular price -
Maple Onion Jam 10.4oz
Vendor:Blake Hill PreservesRegular price $9.99Sale price $9.99 Regular price
Product facts
- Made by
- Keystone Cheese
- Maker based in
- Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
- Size
- 7 oz
- Price per unit
- $1.86 / oz
- Great for
- Topping garlic bread




