Keystone Cheese 7 Year Aged White Cheddar

Keystone Cheese at Madeline's

Keystone Cheese, also known as Keystone Farms Cheese, is a Bethlehem, Pennsylvania cheese company that specializes in handcrafted Wisconsin artisan cheese. Owner Nikole started the business in 2014 after years of traveling between Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, where she found a depth of cheese quality and flavor that was not available back home.

Rather than making cheese in Pennsylvania, Keystone works directly with small family factories and farms across Wisconsin to source its lineup. The cheeses are made from 100% Wisconsin cow's milk in small batches, with no preservatives, no artificial flavors or colors, and no added hormones. The range covers everything from aged cheddars and everyday table cheeses to flavored and infused styles.

The catalog runs deep on cheddar, with white cheddars aged from two years up to fifteen, plus fruit-infused versions like cranberry and cinnamon apple. Alongside the cheddars are classics such as gouda, baby Swiss, muenster, and provolone, Sartori's BellaVitano wedges, LaClare goat cheeses, and a line of cold-pack cheese spreads in flavors like port wine and Italian truffle.

Keystone Cheese products at Madeline's

A selection of Keystone Cheese's live, in-stock products at Madeline's is below. Click any product for full details and ordering.

  • 2 Year Aged White Cheddar from Keystone Cheese

    2 Year Aged White Cheddar (from $8). A smooth, mellow Wisconsin white cheddar aged two years. Sold in several sizes.

  • 5 Year Aged Cheddar from Keystone Cheese

    5 Year Aged Cheddar (from $13). A sharper white cheddar aged five years, with developing crystals. Sold in several sizes.

  • 7 Year Aged White Cheddar from Keystone Cheese

    7 Year Aged White Cheddar (from $16). A sharp, crystalline white cheddar aged seven years. Sold in several sizes.

  • 12 Year Aged Cheddar from Keystone Cheese

    12 Year Aged Cheddar (from $33). An extra-sharp white cheddar aged twelve years, dense and crystalline. Sold in several sizes.

  • 15 Year Aged Cheddar from Keystone Cheese

    15 Year Aged Cheddar (from $50). One of the most aged cheddars in the lineup, aged fifteen years for intense sharpness. Sold in several sizes.

  • Cranberry Infused Cheddar from Keystone Cheese

    Cranberry Infused Cheddar (from $9). Cheddar studded with dried cranberries, a sweet-tart pairing for a board. Sold in several sizes.

  • Cinnamon Apple Cheddar from Keystone Cheese

    Cinnamon Apple Cheddar (from $9). Cheddar infused with cinnamon and apple for a dessert-leaning flavor. Sold in several sizes.

  • Baby Swiss from Keystone Cheese

    Baby Swiss (from $17). A mild, buttery Swiss with small eyes. Sold in several sizes.

  • Gouda from Keystone Cheese

    Gouda (from $14). A creamy, mild gouda. Sold in several sizes.

  • Smoked Gouda from Keystone Cheese

    Smoked Gouda (from $11). Gouda with a smoky flavor. Sold in several sizes.

  • Muenster from Keystone Cheese

    Muenster (from $13). A mild, smooth muenster that melts well. Sold in several sizes.

  • Provolone from Keystone Cheese

    Provolone (from $11). A semi-firm Italian-style table cheese. Sold in several sizes.

  • BellaVitano Merlot from Keystone Cheese

    BellaVitano Merlot ($10). A Sartori BellaVitano wedge soaked in merlot wine, fruity and nutty.

  • BellaVitano Espresso from Keystone Cheese

    BellaVitano Espresso ($10). A Sartori BellaVitano wedge rubbed with espresso for a nutty, coffee-edged flavor.

  • LaClare Original Goat Cheese from Keystone Cheese

    LaClare Original Goat Cheese ($8). A fresh, tangy goat cheese log from Wisconsin's LaClare Family Creamery.

  • LaClare Fig & Honey Goat Cheese from Keystone Cheese

    LaClare Fig & Honey Goat Cheese ($8). Fresh goat cheese blended with fig and honey for a sweet finish.

  • Port Wine Cheese Spread from Keystone Cheese

    Port Wine Cheese Spread ($11). A cold-pack cheddar spread flavored with port wine, ready for crackers.

  • Italian Truffle Cheese Spread from Keystone Cheese

    Italian Truffle Cheese Spread ($11). A cold-pack cheese spread with Italian truffle flavor.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I buy Keystone Cheese products?

You can buy Keystone Cheese online at Madeline's (madelines.co), which carries the company's aged cheddars, classic and flavored cheeses, BellaVitano wedges, LaClare goat cheeses, and cheese spreads. The products listed above are live and in stock.

Where is Keystone Cheese based?

Keystone Cheese, also known as Keystone Farms Cheese, is based in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. It was founded in 2014 by owner Nikole, who sources handcrafted artisan cheese directly from small family factories and farms in Wisconsin.

What is Keystone Cheese made from?

Keystone's cheeses are made from 100% Wisconsin cow's milk in small batches, with no preservatives, no artificial flavors or colors, and no added hormones.

How aged are the cheddars?

Keystone's white cheddars are aged from two years up to fifteen years, so you can pick a mellow two-year cheddar or a sharp, crystalline twelve- or fifteen-year wheel.

Back to blog