Mustard

Madeline's Mustard collection brings together small-batch mustards from independent US makers, from everyday yellow and honey mustards to bold specialty blends. It is best for anyone who wants a craft mustard for sandwiches, pretzels, dressings, and glazes. The featured picks below are in stock and.

Read the buying guide and FAQ15 productsIn stock only

Start here

Madeline's Mustard collection brings together small-batch mustards from independent US makers, from everyday yellow and honey mustards to bold specialty blends. It is best for anyone who wants a craft mustard for sandwiches, pretzels, dressings, and glazes. The featured picks below are in stock and ready to ship.

How to choose

  • Everyday or specialty. Yellow and honey mustards are versatile, while specialty blends like horseradish, dill pickle, or truffle add a distinct twist.
  • Sweet or sharp. Honey mustard is mild and sweet, while classic and horseradish styles are sharper.
  • Match to use. Mustards work on sandwiches and pretzels, in vinaigrettes, and as a glaze for meat.

Featured picks

Frequently asked questions

What mustards are in this collection? Small-batch yellow, honey, and specialty mustards from independent makers. The featured picks are in stock and ship nationwide.

What is honey mustard good for? Honey mustard is mild and sweet, which makes it good as a sandwich spread, a pretzel or chicken dip, and a base for dressings and glazes.

How should I store mustard? Refrigerate mustard after opening to keep its flavor and color, and follow the date on the label.

Related collections