Gift ideas from independent makers
Olive Oil Gifts Under $25
A bottle of good olive oil is a gift people cook with the same week. Everything below is under $25 and in stock, from makers like Seasons Olive Oil & Vinegar, Bill's Premium Olive Oil and Jovial Foods. Smaller bottles start under $10, so two from the same maker fit the budget and ship in one box.
-
Coratina Extra Virgin Olive Oil - NEW HARVEST 2025
Vendor:Seasons Olive Oil & VinegarRegular price $21.95Sale price $21.95 Regular price -
Mini Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Vendor:Jovial Foods, IncRegular price $5.79Sale price $5.79 Regular price -
Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 500 ml
Vendor:Jovial Foods, IncRegular price $21.99Sale price $21.99 Regular price -
Arbequina Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Vendor:Donkey ProvisionsRegular price $23.99Sale price $23.99 Regular price -
100% Cold-Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Vendor:Bill's Premium Olive OilRegular price $24.00Sale price $24.00 Regular price -
Basil Extra Virgin Olive Oil (100mL)
Vendor:Angel's Salumi & TrufflesRegular price $8.29Sale price $8.29 Regular price -
Orange Extra Virgin Olive Oil (100mL)
Vendor:Angel's Salumi & TrufflesRegular price $8.29Sale price $8.29 Regular price -
Pesto Infused Olive Oil
Vendor:Seasons Olive Oil & VinegarRegular price From $8.00Sale price From $8.00 Regular price
Good to know
How does shipping work?
Each maker packs and ships its own items, so shipping is calculated per maker at checkout, usually $8 to $15 for a single item. Adding more from the same maker spreads the cost; the product page shows what else they make.
Can I send this as a gift?
Yes. Enter the recipient's address at checkout and add a gift note in the cart. Perishable items go out Monday to Wednesday in insulated packaging so they never sit over a weekend.
What if I want more than one maker?
Mix as many makers as you like in one cart with one checkout and no account. Each maker ships its own box.
Are these really under $25?
Every pick on this page is priced under $25 before shipping and is in stock right now. Prices come straight from the makers; the list refreshes as inventory changes.
- Cheese gifts under $25
- Cheese gifts under $50
- Cheese gifts under $100
- Charcuterie gifts under $50
- Charcuterie gifts under $100
- Coffee gifts under $25
- Coffee gifts under $50
- Tea gifts under $50
- Chocolate gifts under $25
- Chocolate gifts under $50
- Hot sauce gifts under $25
- Hot sauce gifts under $50
- Honey gifts under $25
- Honey gifts under $50
- Jerky gifts under $50
- Gift boxes under $50
- Gift boxes under $100
- Thank-you gifts under $50
- Hostess gifts under $25
- Hostess gifts under $50
- Housewarming gifts under $50
- Coworker gifts under $25
- Birthday food gifts under $50
- Holiday food gifts under $50
- Tea gifts under $25
- Jam gifts under $25
- Granola gifts under $25
- Soap gifts under $25
- BBQ gifts under $25
- Pasta gifts under $25
- Snack gifts under $25
- Teacher gifts under $25
- Gifts for dad under $50
- Gifts for mom under $50
- Gifts for foodies under $50
- Coworker gifts under $50
- Gluten-free gifts under $50





