Secret Santa

Secret Santa food gifts under $25

Under $25 is enough for a Secret Santa gift people actually want if it comes from someone who makes one thing well. A three-honey flight from Mickelberry Gardens, a peppermint dark milk chocolate bar from Maui Kuʻia Estate in Lahaina, Carolina Reaper hot honey from Elijah's Xtreme, bourbon smoked pecans from Louisville. Every pick is in stock and under $25 before shipping.

9 picks, in stock today. Each ships straight from its maker.

When you don't know them well

Pick something most people like: a tea sampler, hot cocoa, chocolate or biscotti. Save the hot honey for the person who puts hot sauce on everything.

Two small things

A chocolate bar and a bag of Christmas tea come in under $25 together and look like more than one gift.

Good to know

What is a good Secret Santa gift under $25?

A honey flight ($19.79), a box of 16 tea bags from Piper and Leaf ($23.99), single-origin hot cocoa ($16), bourbon smoked pecans ($17.50) or a peppermint chocolate bar ($7.50). All are on this page and in stock.

Are these really under $25?

Every pick here is priced under $25 before shipping and is in stock right now. Prices come straight from the makers and can change.

How does shipping work?

Each maker packs and ships its own items, so shipping is each maker's own rate, shown at checkout, usually $8 to $15 for one item. Anything else from the same maker goes in the same box. Perishables like cheese go out Monday to Wednesday in insulated packaging.