White elephant

White elephant food gifts worth stealing

The best white elephant gift is the strange one everybody ends up wanting. Bacon ketchup and Gator Jam from Savannah Sauce Company, a caramelized onion dark chocolate bar from Goodnow Farms, habanero pickle juice cocktail mix from Cin Chili in Houston, jet-black popcorn kernels from Dell Cove. Most are under $20, and every one is in stock.

9 picks, in stock today. Each ships straight from its maker.

Odd but good

Pick something people will talk about and then eat: a dark chocolate bar with caramelized onion, or a hot sauce made from kimchi.

Stay under the limit

Most groups set a limit around $20 or $25. These picks are priced under $20 before shipping, so two small jars can still fit.

Good to know

What is a good white elephant food gift?

Something unexpected that still tastes good: bacon ketchup, Gator Jam pepper jam, a caramelized onion dark chocolate bar, a Carolina Reaper hot honey or black popcorn kernels.

What if they don't like spicy food?

Pick from the milder side: bacon ketchup, everything bagel cashews, black popcorn kernels or one of the chocolate bars.

How does shipping work?

Each maker packs and ships its own items, so shipping is each maker's own rate, shown at checkout, usually $8 to $15 for one item. Anything else from the same maker goes in the same box. Perishables like cheese go out Monday to Wednesday in insulated packaging.