Where to Buy a Cheese Gift Box Online
Where can you buy a cheese gift box online? You can buy one here, at Madeline's. We are a curated marketplace of independent US creameries, and there are two reliable ways to send cheese as a gift: pick a ready-made cheese box, or build your own from in-stock cheeses and have it shipped together. Our Cheese collection and Gift Boxes collection are where both paths start.
A marketplace has one real advantage for cheese gifting: range. Instead of a single creamery's lineup, you can combine cheeses from several small US makers, like Smith's Country Cheese in Winchendon, Massachusetts and Cheese Brothers in Wisconsin, into one order. Below are real, in-stock options you can send today.
Ready-to-gift cheese boxes in stock now
-
Smith's 12-Count Variety Pack Cheddar Cheese Stick Box ($19.99): A boxed set covering Smith's cheddar stick lineup from mild to smoky, individually wrapped. An easy, affordable cheese gift that ships and stores well.
-
Smith's Chive Cheddar Cheese Stick Box ($19.99): Twelve individually wrapped chive cheddar sticks in a giftable box. Good for a single-flavor gift or a snack box.
Build your own cheese gift box
The most flexible option is to pick a few cheeses across styles and ship them together. Aim for a range: a sharp aged cheddar, a mild gouda, an alpine or havarti, and a soft spread for variety. These are all in stock.
-
Cheese Brothers 8-Year-Aged Cheddar ($12.95): A long-aged cheddar with crystalline crunch and deep flavor. The "wow" cheese in a gift box.
-
Cheese Brothers Classic Gouda ($8.95): A smooth, crowd-friendly gouda that balances the sharper cheeses.
-
Cheese Brothers Adelheid Alpine-Style Cheese ($8.95): A nutty, melt-friendly alpine cheese that adds range to a board.
-
Cheese Brothers Cranberry Walnut Cheese Spread ($9.95): A sweet-savory spread that rounds out a gift box and works on crackers right away.
-
Smith's Smoked Farmstead Gouda ($9): Cold-smoked over hardwood, with caramel and a long finish.
-
Smith's Extra Sharp Cheddar ($9): A bold farmstead cheddar for the sharp-cheese lover on your list.
-
Eichten's Smoked Gouda ($6.50): A budget-friendly smoked gouda from a Minnesota creamery to fill out the box.
Browse everything in the Cheese collection, or see assembled sets in the Gift Boxes collection. Cheese Brothers builds multi-cheese assortment boxes that rotate in and out of stock there.
How to choose a cheese gift box
- Balance the styles. A good box has contrast: one sharp, one mild, one firm, one spreadable. The build-your-own picks above are chosen to do exactly that.
- Match the recipient. For a snacker, the cheese stick boxes are ideal. For a cheese-board host, mix aged cheddar, gouda, and a spread.
- Add accompaniments. Crackers, jam, and honey turn a cheese box into a full board. Our cheese-board jam guide has pairing ideas.
- Mind shipping and storage. Cheese ships chilled and should be refrigerated on arrival. Hard, aged cheeses keep longest.
Frequently asked questions
Where is the best place to buy a cheese gift box online?
A curated marketplace like Madeline's lets you either buy a ready-made cheese box or build your own from several small US creameries in one order. The Cheese and Gift Boxes collections are the starting points, with in-stock boxes from Smith's Country Cheese and cheeses from Cheese Brothers.
Can I build my own cheese gift box?
Yes. Add a few cheeses across styles to one order, for example an aged cheddar, a gouda, an alpine cheese, and a spread, and they ship together. That is often a better value and more personal than a fixed assortment.
How many cheeses should a gift box include?
Three to five cheeses is a good range for one or two people, giving variety without waste. Scale up for a larger household or a party.
Does cheese need to be refrigerated when shipped as a gift?
Yes. Cheese is shipped chilled and should be refrigerated when it arrives. Hard, aged cheeses are the most forgiving in transit and keep the longest once opened.
What should I add to a cheese box to make it a full board?
Crackers, a jam or preserve, honey, and some cured meat round out a cheese gift into a board. See our guide on how to build a charcuterie and cheese board.