Where to Buy a Cheese Gift Box Online
Where can you buy a cheese gift box online? You can buy one here, at Madeline's. We are a curated marketplace of independent creameries, and there are two reliable ways to send cheese as a gift: pick a ready-made cheese box, or build your own from in-stock cheeses and have it shipped together. Our Cheese collection and Gift Boxes collection are where both paths start.
A marketplace has one real advantage for cheese gifting: range. Instead of a single creamery's lineup, you can combine cheeses from several small makers, like Smith's Country Cheese in Winchendon, Massachusetts and Cheese Brothers in Wisconsin, into one order. Below are real, in-stock options you can send today.
Ready-to-gift cheese boxes in stock now
-
Smith's 12-Count Variety Pack Cheddar Cheese Stick Box ($19.99): A boxed set covering Smith's cheddar stick lineup from mild to smoky, individually wrapped. An easy, affordable cheese gift that ships and stores well.
-
Smith's Chive Cheddar Cheese Stick Box ($19.99): Twelve individually wrapped chive cheddar sticks in a giftable box. Good for a single-flavor gift or a snack box.
Build your own cheese gift box
The most flexible option is to pick a few cheeses across styles and ship them together. Aim for a range: a sharp aged cheddar, a mild gouda, an alpine or havarti, and a soft spread for variety. These are all in stock.
-
Cheese Brothers 8-Year-Aged Cheddar ($12.95): A long-aged cheddar with crystalline crunch and deep flavor. The "wow" cheese in a gift box.
-
Smith's Plain Farmstead Gouda ($9): A smooth, semi-firm, crowd-friendly gouda that balances the sharper cheeses.
-
Cheese Brothers Adelheid Alpine-Style Cheese ($8.95): A nutty, melt-friendly alpine cheese that adds range to a board.
-
Cheese Brothers Cranberry Walnut Cheese Spread ($9.95): A sweet-savory spread that rounds out a gift box and works on crackers right away.
-
Smith's Smoked Farmstead Gouda ($9): Cold-smoked over hardwood, with caramel and a long finish.
-
Smith's Extra Sharp Cheddar ($9): A bold farmstead cheddar for the sharp-cheese lover on your list.
-
Eichten's Smoked Gouda ($6.50): A budget-friendly smoked gouda from a Minnesota creamery to fill out the box.
Browse everything in the Cheese collection, or see assembled sets in the Gift Boxes collection. Cheese Brothers builds multi-cheese assortment boxes that rotate in and out of stock there.
How to choose a cheese gift box
- Balance the styles. A good box has contrast: one sharp, one mild, one firm, one spreadable. The build-your-own picks above are chosen to do exactly that.
- Match the recipient. For a snacker, the cheese stick boxes are ideal. For a cheese-board host, mix aged cheddar, gouda, and a spread.
- Add accompaniments. Crackers, jam, and honey turn a cheese box into a full board. Our cheese-board jam guide has pairing ideas.
- Mind shipping and storage. Cheese ships chilled and should be refrigerated on arrival. Hard, aged cheeses keep longest.
Frequently asked questions
Where is the best place to buy a cheese gift box online?
A curated marketplace like Madeline's lets you either buy a ready-made cheese box or build your own from several small creameries in one order. The Cheese and Gift Boxes collections are the starting points, with in-stock boxes from Smith's Country Cheese and cheeses from Cheese Brothers.
Can I build my own cheese gift box?
Yes. Add a few cheeses across styles to one order, for example an aged cheddar, a gouda, an alpine cheese, and a spread, and they ship together. That is often a better value and more personal than a fixed assortment.
How many cheeses should a gift box include?
Three to five cheeses is a good range for one or two people, giving variety without waste. Scale up for a larger household or a party.
Does cheese need to be refrigerated when shipped as a gift?
Yes. Cheese is shipped chilled and should be refrigerated when it arrives. Hard, aged cheeses are the most forgiving in transit and keep the longest once opened.
What should I add to a cheese box to make it a full board?
Crackers, a jam or preserve, honey, and some cured meat round out a cheese gift into a board. See our guide on how to build a charcuterie and cheese board.