Nut Butter

Madeline's Nut Butter collection features simple, small-batch nut and seed butters made with two ingredients or fewer, including peanut, almond, cashew, and tahini. These are clean-label spreads without added oils or sugar, good for toast, smoothies, baking, and dipping. Many are organic. Every item shown.

Read the buying guide and FAQ18 productsIn stock only

Start here

Madeline's Nut Butter collection features simple, small-batch nut and seed butters made with two ingredients or fewer, including peanut, almond, cashew, and tahini. These are clean-label spreads without added oils or sugar, good for toast, smoothies, baking, and dipping. Many are organic. Every item shown is in stock and ready to ship.

How to choose

  • Pick your nut or seed. Peanut butter is classic and budget-friendly; almond and cashew are milder and creamier; tahini is sesame-based and savory.
  • Check the ingredients. These butters are made with two ingredients or fewer, so look for just nuts or seeds and maybe salt.
  • Organic or conventional. Organic Valencia peanut butter and organic tahini are available if that matters for your pantry.
  • How you will use it. Tahini suits dressings and hummus; nut butters suit toast, oatmeal, smoothies, and baking.
  • Stir before use. Natural nut butters separate, so stir in the oil on top before the first use.

Frequently asked questions

Why does natural nut butter separate? Natural nut butters have no added stabilizers, so the natural oil rises to the top. Stir it back in before use and store the jar upside down or in the fridge to slow separation.

What is tahini? Tahini is a smooth paste made from ground sesame seeds. It is savory and slightly bitter, and is used in hummus, dressings, sauces, and baking.

How should I store nut butter? Natural nut butters keep at room temperature for a while, but refrigerating them slows oil separation and rancidity, especially after opening.

Featured picks

  • Valencia Peanut Butter, 2 Ingredients or Less
  • Organic Valencia Peanut Butter, 2 Ingredients or Less
  • Almond Butter, 2 Ingredients
  • Cashew Butter, 2 Ingredients
  • Organic Tahini, 2 Ingredients

Related collections