Hot Sauce

Small-batch hot sauces from mild and fruity to truffle, bourbon-barrel and ghost pepper, made by the people whose names are on the bottle. Variety packs are the easy way in.

Read the buying guide and FAQ97 productsIn stock only

Start here

Madeline's hot sauce collection brings together small-batch sauces from independent US makers like Fat Cat Gourmet and Flavor & Fire, spanning the full heat range from mild green jalapeno table sauces to extract-free superhots built on Carolina Reaper and Trinidad scorpion peppers. Most bottles run between $6 and $15, many are vegan, and the lineup covers everyday cooking sauces, wing sauces, fruit-forward pepper sauces, chili-garlic blends, and gift-ready sampler packs. If you are looking for a craft hot sauce for daily use, a specific pepper, or a spicy gift set, this is where to start.

How to choose

  • Match the heat to your tolerance. Jalapeno and serrano sauces sit in the mild-to-medium range; habanero and chipotle-ghost blends are hot; scorpion and Carolina Reaper sauces are superhot and meant for experienced heat-seekers.
  • Think about the job. Thin, vinegary table sauces are for dashing on eggs, tacos, and pizza; thicker wing and BBQ-style sauces cling to wings and grilled meat; glazes work as a finishing brush.
  • Follow the pepper for flavor. Habanero brings tropical fruitiness, chipotle adds smoke, black garlic and mushroom give savory umami, and fruit blends like papaya or peach lean sweet-hot.
  • Check dietary notes. Many sauces here are vegan and all-natural; ingredient lists are on each product page if you are avoiding added sugar, gluten, or specific allergens.
  • Buying as a gift? Sampler and multi-bottle gift boxes let someone try a range of heat levels without committing to a single bottle.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best hot sauce for wings? A thicker, cling-friendly sauce works best on wings. Medium serrano or jalapeno wing sauces give bright heat that coats well, while spicy BBQ-style sauces add sweetness and body. For a gift, the grill-focused sampler boxes pair several wing-friendly sauces together.

What is the hottest sauce you carry? The hottest sauces in this collection are built on Carolina Reaper and Trinidad scorpion peppers, which are among the spiciest chilies grown. These are extra-hot and best used a drop at a time. Look for "Reaper" or "scorpion" in the product name.

Are these hot sauces vegan and all-natural? Many of the sauces here are vegan and made with all-natural ingredients, including the chili-garlic and jalapeno lines. Check the individual product page for the full ingredient list and any specific dietary labeling.

What is a good mild hot sauce for someone new to spice? Green jalapeno and "surprisingly mild" pepper sauces lead with flavor over heat, so they add brightness without overwhelming a dish. The mild-heat gift boxes are a low-risk way to find a favorite.

How long does an opened bottle of hot sauce last? Most vinegar-based hot sauces keep for many months. Refrigerate after opening to preserve color and flavor, and check the maker's label for their specific guidance.

Related guides

Read our guides to The Best Hot Sauces for Chicken Wings and The Best Spicy Food Gifts for the Heat-Seeker.

Related collections