Affordable picks from across the catalog — gifts, pantry staples, and treats all priced under $20. Related collections Gifts Under $25Gifts Under $50Tea Gifts Under $25Chocolate Gifts Under $25 Related guides Best Food Gifts Under 25Best Stocking Stuffers Under 15Find the Right Gift Box for.
Start here
-
Cold Pack for Shipping
Vendor:Madeline'sRegular price $5.00Sale price $5.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Traditional Fresh Farmer's Cheese
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Vendor:Nicola's MarketplaceRegular price $18.99Sale price $18.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per
-
BellaVitano Merlot
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Olive Cheddar
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $12.00Sale price From $12.00 Regular priceUnit price per$0.00 -
Italian Truffle Cheese Spread
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
LaClare Original Goat Cheese
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
LaClare Blueberry Vanilla Goat Cheese
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cherry Infused Cheddar
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $10.00Sale price From $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Smoked Gouda
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $11.00Sale price From $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Sarvecchio Parmesan
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Spicy Beer Cheese Spread
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cranberry Infused Cheddar
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $9.00Sale price From $9.00 Regular priceUnit price per$0.00 -
Asiago w/ Rosemary
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Horseradish Havarti
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $13.00Sale price From $13.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Garlic & Herb Cheese Spread
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Port Wine Cheese Spread
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
BellaVitano Espresso
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cinnamon Apple Cheddar
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $9.00Sale price From $9.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Baby Swiss
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $17.00Sale price From $17.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Mozzarella
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $14.00Sale price From $14.00 Regular priceUnit price per$0.00 -
LaClare Chipotle Honey Goat Cheese
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Dill Havarti
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $13.00Sale price From $13.00 Regular priceUnit price per$0.00 -
LaClare Garlic & Herb Goat Cheese
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
LaClare Fig & Honey Goat Cheese
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chai Time Granola (pouch)
Vendor:Flatbush Granola CompanyRegular price From $14.00Sale price From $14.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chai Time Granola (Jar)
Vendor:Flatbush Granola CompanyRegular price From $15.00Sale price From $15.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Marinara Classico – Garlic & Basil Tomato Sauce
Vendor:Ciao PappyRegular price $12.99Sale price $12.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Classic Honey
Vendor:Adee Honey FarmsRegular price From $11.00Sale price From $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Juusto filled with 5 year Cheddar, 6 oz
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price $11.49Sale price $11.49 Regular priceUnit price per -
Juusto with Jalapeno Peppers, 6 oz
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price $11.49Sale price $11.49 Regular priceUnit price per -
Juusto Italiano, 6 oz
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price $11.49Sale price $11.49 Regular priceUnit price per
Sold out right now
Leave your email and we will send one note when the maker restocks it. No newsletter, no promises on when.
Affordable picks from across the catalog — gifts, pantry staples, and treats all priced under $20.