Affordable picks from across the catalog — gifts, pantry staples, and treats all priced under $20. Related collections Gifts Under $25Gifts Under $50Tea Gifts Under $25Chocolate Gifts Under $25 Related guides Best Food Gifts Under 25Best Stocking Stuffers Under 15Find the Right Gift Box for.
Start here
-
Cold Pack for Shipping
Vendor:Madeline'sRegular price $5.00Sale price $5.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Traditional Fresh Farmer's Cheese
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Vendor:Nicola's MarketplaceRegular price $18.99Sale price $18.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per
-
Cold Pack for Shipping
Vendor:Madeline'sRegular price $5.00Sale price $5.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Traditional Fresh Farmer's Cheese
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Vendor:Nicola's MarketplaceRegular price $18.99Sale price $18.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Wild Maine Blueberry Preserve (small batch)
Vendor:BleuberetRegular price $15.00Sale price $15.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Pumpkin spice creamed honey
Vendor:Pearl Honey SpreadsRegular price $13.00Sale price $13.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Creamy Gouda Spread
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
"Bluegrass" Bourbon Gouda
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $8.95Sale price $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Tamarind Paste, Certified Organic - 11 oz
Vendor:Pure Indian FoodsRegular price $11.99Sale price $11.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Dips & Spreads
Vendor:Argyle Cheese FarmerRegular price From $7.39Sale price From $7.39 Regular priceUnit price per -
Hard Cheeses
Vendor:Argyle Cheese FarmerRegular price From $9.18Sale price From $9.18 Regular priceUnit price per -
Greek Yogurt
Vendor:Argyle Cheese FarmerRegular price From $8.55Sale price From $8.55 Regular priceUnit price per -
Oak Smoked Salt
Vendor:Texas Salt CoRegular price From $10.00Sale price From $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Seasonal Jam: Mango Preserve
Vendor:Food with RootsRegular price $8.00Sale price $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Famiglia Crispino Spicy Arrabbiata Bruschetta Spread — Hot Pepper Italian Antipasto
Vendor:Famiglia CrispinoRegular price $15.00Sale price $15.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Famiglia Crispino Sun-Dried Tomato Antipasto — Italian Marinated in Olive Oil
Vendor:Famiglia CrispinoRegular price $12.99Sale price $12.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Famiglia Crispino Porcini Mushroom Bruschetta Spread — Wild Italian Funghi
Vendor:Famiglia CrispinoRegular price $14.99Sale price $14.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Paulman Acre - Smoke a Peach Hot Sauce
Vendor:California Hot Sauce SolutionsRegular price $10.95Sale price $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
J's Small Batch - Mustard Glen Hot Sauce
Vendor:California Hot Sauce SolutionsRegular price $12.95Sale price $12.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Paulman Acre - Fermented Garlic Hot Sauce
Vendor:California Hot Sauce SolutionsRegular price $10.95Sale price $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Paulman Acre - Don’t Pear the Reaper Hot Sauce
Vendor:California Hot Sauce SolutionsRegular price $10.95Sale price $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
CHSS - The Subtle Tease Hot Sauce
Vendor:California Hot Sauce SolutionsRegular price $10.95Sale price $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Napa Cabbage Kimchi
Vendor:Ji's KimchiRegular price From $13.00Sale price From $13.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Beef & Pork Bolognese Ravioli
Vendor:Nicola's MarketplaceRegular price $18.99Sale price $18.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Kona Blend
Vendor:Reading Coffee CompanyRegular price From $8.00Sale price From $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Semuliki Forest, Uganda 75% Dark Chocolate
Vendor:Xocolatl Small Batch ChocolateRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Pure 100% Dark Chocolate
Vendor:Xocolatl Small Batch ChocolateRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Pre-Sliced Italian Toscano Salami (3oz)
Vendor:Angel's Salumi & TrufflesRegular price $8.83Sale price $8.83 Regular priceUnit price per -
Pre-Sliced Black Truffle Salami (3oz)
Vendor:Angel's Salumi & TrufflesRegular price $9.00Sale price $9.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheese Ravioli
Vendor:Nicola's MarketplaceRegular price $14.99Sale price $14.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Hot Pepper Gouda Spread
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Gouda With Sundried Tomato & Basil Spread
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Caramelized Fig with Pear & Honey 10.8oz
Vendor:Blake Hill PreservesRegular price $9.99Sale price $9.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
"Taggiasca" Olives in Brine (300g)
Vendor:Angel's Salumi & TrufflesRegular price $7.89Sale price $7.89 Regular priceUnit price per -
Ligurian Artichoke Paste (90g)
Vendor:Angel's Salumi & TrufflesRegular price $6.69Sale price $6.69 Regular priceUnit price per -
Ligurian Pepper Paste (90g)
Vendor:Angel's Salumi & TrufflesRegular price $6.69Sale price $6.69 Regular priceUnit price per
Sold out right now
Leave your email and we will send one note when the maker restocks it. No newsletter, no promises on when.
Affordable picks from across the catalog — gifts, pantry staples, and treats all priced under $20.