Affordable picks from across the catalog — gifts, pantry staples, and treats all priced under $20. Related collections Gifts Under $25Gifts Under $50Tea Gifts Under $25Chocolate Gifts Under $25 Related guides Best Food Gifts Under 25Best Stocking Stuffers Under 15Find the Right Gift Box for.
Start here
-
Cold Pack for Shipping
Vendor:Madeline'sRegular price $5.00Sale price $5.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Traditional Fresh Farmer's Cheese
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Vendor:Nicola's MarketplaceRegular price $18.99Sale price $18.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per
-
Special Reserve, Las Palomas Coffee
Vendor:Goodnow Farms ChocolateRegular price $18.00Sale price $18.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Herbaceous Green Sichuan Pepper
Vendor:Goodnow Farms ChocolateRegular price $18.00Sale price $18.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch Bark
Vendor:GranolachikRegular price From $14.99Sale price From $14.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chocolate Brownie Crunch Bark
Vendor:GranolachikRegular price From $14.99Sale price From $14.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Classic BBQ Sauce
Vendor:Flavor & FireRegular price $9.00Sale price $9.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chocolate Fresh Farmer's Cheese
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $6.00Sale price $6.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chili Pepper Cheddar Cheese Stick Box
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $19.99Sale price $19.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chipotle-Rubbed Farmstead Gouda
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chive Cheddar
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chili Pepper Cheddar
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $10.00Sale price $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Chive Cheddar Cheese Stick Box
Vendor:Smith's Country CheeseRegular price $19.99Sale price $19.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Silky Smooth Sprouted Almond Butter w/ Coconut Oil & Vanilla
Vendor:Philosopher FoodsRegular price From $11.79Sale price From $11.79 Regular priceUnit price per -
Organic Roasted Cacao Nibs
Vendor:Xocolatl Small Batch ChocolateRegular price $14.00Sale price $14.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
2 Year Aged White Cheddar
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $8.00Sale price From $8.00 Regular priceUnit price per$0.00 -
Sale5 Year Aged Cheddar
Vendor:Keystone CheeseRegular price From $13.00Sale price From $13.00 Regular priceUnit price per$14.00Sale -
Garlic and Dill Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily*
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $8.95Sale price From $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Jalapeño Pepper Cheese Spread
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $9.95Sale price $9.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Classic Gouda
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $8.95Sale price $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Smoked Cheddar
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $8.95Sale price $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Tomato Basil Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily*
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $8.95Sale price From $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Adelheid Alpine-Style Cheese
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $8.95Sale price $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cranberry Walnut Cheese Spread
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $9.95Sale price $9.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Smoked Provolone
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $8.95Sale price $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Barron Sausage Co. Summer Sausage
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $10.95Sale price $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Bacon Golden Baked Bliss Cheese
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $10.95Sale price From $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Italian Golden Baked Bliss Cheese
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $10.95Sale price From $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Jalapeño Golden Baked Bliss
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $10.95Sale price From $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Port Wine Cheese Spread
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $9.95Sale price $9.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheese Brothers Cutting Board
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $9.95Sale price $9.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Ranch Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily*
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $8.95Sale price From $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Hot Pepper Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily*
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $8.95Sale price From $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Golden Baked Bliss Cheese
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price From $10.95Sale price From $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Caesar dressing
Vendor:Hanley's FoodsRegular price $6.00Sale price $6.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cranberry Classic (jar)
Vendor:Flatbush Granola CompanyRegular price From $10.00Sale price From $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Creamy Calabrian Marinara Sauce
Vendor:Ciao PappyRegular price $12.99Sale price $12.99 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheese and Bacon
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price From $4.49Sale price From $4.49 Regular priceUnit price per
Sold out right now
Leave your email and we will send one note when the maker restocks it. No newsletter, no promises on when.
Affordable picks from across the catalog — gifts, pantry staples, and treats all priced under $20.