Real food gifts under $25 from small makers: creamed honey, farmstead cheese, hot sauce, preserves and more. Add a few from the same maker and they ship together.
Start here
-
Pumpkin spice creamed honey
Vendor:Pearl Honey SpreadsRegular price $13.00Sale price $13.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
"Bluegrass" Bourbon Gouda
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $8.95Sale price $8.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
J's Small Batch - Mustard Glen Hot Sauce
Vendor:California Hot Sauce SolutionsRegular price $12.95Sale price $12.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Caramelized Fig with Pear & Honey 10.8oz
Vendor:Blake Hill PreservesRegular price $9.99Sale price $9.99 Regular priceUnit price per
-
Ghost Chili Pepper Jack
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price From $7.25Sale price From $7.25 Regular priceUnit price per -
Jalapeno Pepper Jack
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price From $6.75Sale price From $6.75 Regular priceUnit price per -
Mild Gouda, Approx wt. 12oz
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price $9.49Sale price $9.49 Regular priceUnit price per -
Mousehouse Jack (Exclusive!)
Vendor:Mousehouse CheesehausRegular price From $5.75Sale price From $5.75 Regular priceUnit price per -
Jalapeño Pepper Cheese Spread
Vendor:Cheese Brothers, Inc.Regular price $9.95Sale price $9.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
DRIED WOOD EAR MUSHROOMS
Vendor:Mushroom MountainRegular price $15.00Sale price $15.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Aleppo Chili Pepper
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $7.90Sale price From $7.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Hip Bone - Memphis BBQ Sauce
Vendor:California Hot Sauce SolutionsRegular price $10.95Sale price $10.95 Regular priceUnit price per -
Marash Chile Flakes
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $6.90Sale price From $6.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Black Walnut Flavoring
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $9.00Sale price From $9.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Bourbon Flavoring
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $10.00Sale price From $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Kilombero Valley, Tanzania 73%
Vendor:Xocolatl Small Batch ChocolateRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Matagalpa, Nicaragua, 72% Dark Chocolate Bar
Vendor:Xocolatl Small Batch ChocolateRegular price $11.00Sale price $11.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Ancho Honey Rub
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $5.90Sale price From $5.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Joey's Hot Honey With Saffron (Took Gold In The European Hot Sauce Awards)
Vendor:Joey's Hot SauceRegular price $15.00Sale price $15.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Reaper Hot Sauce
Vendor:Elijah's XtremeRegular price $14.00Sale price $14.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Greenhorn Sampler - Wild Boar
Vendor:Pearson Ranch JerkyRegular price $16.69Sale price $16.69 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cherry Flavoring
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $10.00Sale price From $10.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Pasilla Negro Powder
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $8.90Sale price From $8.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Pure Lemon Extract
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $9.00Sale price From $9.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Pure Almond Extract
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $9.00Sale price From $9.00 Regular priceUnit price per -
Smoked Serrano Powder
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $7.90Sale price From $7.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Cowboy Steak Rub
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $6.90Sale price From $6.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Jamaican Jerk, Mild
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $6.90Sale price From $6.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
White Peppercorn, Ground
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $9.90Sale price From $9.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Four Peppercorn Blend, Whole
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $7.90Sale price From $7.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
White Peppercorn, Whole
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $15.90Sale price From $15.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Four Peppercorn Blend, Ground
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $7.90Sale price From $7.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Red Szechuan Peppercorn
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $6.20Sale price From $6.20 Regular priceUnit price per -
Green Peppercorn
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $8.90Sale price From $8.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Smoked Black Peppercorn
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $8.90Sale price From $8.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Black Peppercorn, Ground
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $5.90Sale price From $5.90 Regular priceUnit price per -
Black Peppercorn, Butcher Cut
Vendor:Old Town Spice ShopRegular price From $6.90Sale price From $6.90 Regular priceUnit price per
Sold out right now
Leave your email and we will send one note when the maker restocks it. No newsletter, no promises on when.
Affordable food gifts under $25, all in stock and ready to ship nationwide. This collection gathers in-stock, giftable foods from independent makers priced at $25 and under, with bulk and wholesale packs excluded so every pick is a ready-to-give single. It is a fast answer to "best food gift under $25" and "affordable foodie gift," spanning jams and preserves, granola, hot sauces, honey, snacks, and pantry treats. Most items are shelf-stable and ship to all 50 states.
How to choose a food gift under $25
- For a sweet tooth, choose a granola, jam, or chocolate treat.
- For a spice lover, pick a small-batch hot sauce or chili condiment.
- For a host or pantry gift, reach for honey, preserves, or a pickled jar.
- Check the product page for dietary notes such as gluten-free, low-sugar, or vegan.
Featured picks (in stock, ship nationwide)
- Pure Honey & Oats Granola (12oz) (about $6) - best for an everyday breakfast gift.
- Raspberry Jam (about $6) - best for a classic preserve.
- Devil's Lightning Bhut Jolokia Hot Sauce (about $12) - best for the heat seeker.
- Southern Style Beets (about $7) - best for a tangy pickled jar.
- Triple C Steak Sauce (about $9) - best for the griller.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good food gift under $25? A jar of small-batch jam, a bag of granola, a bottle of hot sauce, or local honey all make strong food gifts under $25 and are in stock here.
Do these gifts ship nationwide? Yes. The items in this collection are shelf-stable and ship to all 50 states.
Are there dietary-friendly options? Yes. Low-sugar, gluten-free, and vegan items are available; check the product page for details.


































